The The Texas Conservative Liberty Forum supports the compilation, reporting, and application of objective scientific data for use in all science-based endeavor, and especially so when it comes to the application of medical treatment to living human beings.
Senate Bill 1188 establishes new electronic record requirements established for patient medical records for covered, new restrictions on sharing and storing records to protect patient information, and requirement added to include biological sex in patient records under the new privacy protections.
Healthcare providers in Texas need to have access to essential clinical data—
specifically, a patient’s biological sex in the patient’s medical record for what should be obvious reasons. From diagnosis to treatment and long-term care planning, biological sex is often a critical variable. It is often said by opponents of this bill that we need to “trust the professionals.” They should know that leading research medical research institutions, including the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and the Mayo Clinic, emphasize that biological sex plays a critical role in understanding disease risk, symptom presentation, treatment response, recovery outcomes and healthcare data.
For example, the American Heart Association has found that females are more likely to experience non-classic heart attack symptoms, different from males. Knowing this in a critical situation can be lifesaving. In other cases, failure to know the actual sex of a patient can lead to serious negative consequences, as when a female that identified as a man was misdiagnosed with stomach pain because the staff did not know the actual sex of the patient, resulting in an avoidable stillbirth (reported in the May 16, 2019 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine).
Note that HB4503 does not prohibit healthcare providers from including a patient’s gender identity in medical records. This bill only ensures biological sex is documented for clinical effectiveness, while still allowing space for are that respects every patient.
The Texas Conservative Liberty Forum supports HB4503 for real science, for good medical care, and for plain and good common sense.
***
Senate Vote: 23 Yeas (incl. 3 Ds), 8 Nays.
House Vote: 86 Yeas (incl. 6 Ds), 49 Nays, 3 Present, 12 Absent